By John Byrne
May 11th, 2010
Elena Kagan, President Barack Obama’s latest nominee to the Supreme Court,
helped protect the Saudi royal family from lawsuits that sought to hold al Qaeda
financiers responsible in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks.
The suits were filed by thousands of family members and others affected by
the Sept. 11 attacks. In court papers, they provided evidence that members of
the Saudi royal family had channeled millions to al Qaeda prior to the bombings,
often in contravention of direct guidance from the United States.
But Kagan, acting as President Obama’s Solicitor General, argued that the case
should not be heard even if evidence proved that the Saudis helped underwrite
al Qaeda, because it would interfere with US foreign policy with the oil-rich
nation. She posited “that the princes are immune from petitioners’
claims” because of “the potentially significant foreign relations
consequences of subjecting another sovereign state to suit.”
In an interview with the Philadelphia Inquirer published Tuesday,
the mother of a man who was killed on United Flight 93 in Pennsylvania said
he didn’t know why Kagan argued that the case not even be heard. By keeping
the case off the dockets, the Saudis were spared scrutiny of their finances.
“We had hoped she would be with us so that we could have our day in court,"
Beverly Burnett said.
I find this reprehensible,” said Kristen Breitweiser, another family
member whose husband was killed in the 9/11 attacks, said
at the time. “One would have hoped that the Obama administration would
have taken a different stance than the Bush administration, and you wonder what
message this sends to victims of terrorism around the world.”
The Obama Administration’s decision to intervene in the Saudi-al Qaeda case
so irritated two Republican senators that they introduced legislation aiming
to ensure that Americans have the ability to sue foreign governments.
Sen. Arlen Specter (D-PA) and Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) offered a proposal
to amend the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, which Kagan cited as one reason
the Saudi case should not be heard. Both senators said that US citizens should
be able to sue foreign governments if they are found to be supporting terrorist
Specter, who has since become a Democrat, was unusually blunt.
"She wants to coddle the Saudis," he said.