By Paul Haven
April 16, 2009
MADRID (AP) — Spain’s attorney general has rejected opening an investigation
into whether six Bush administration officials sanctioned torture against terror
suspects at Guantánamo Bay, saying Thursday a U.S. courtroom would be the proper
Candido Conde-Pumpido’s remarks severely dampen the chance of a case moving
forward against the Americans, including former U.S. Attorney General Alberto
Gonzales. Conde-Pumpido said such a trial would have turned Spain’s National
Court “into a plaything” to be used for political ends.
“If there is a reason to file a complaint against these people, it should
be done before local courts with jurisdiction, in other words in the United
States,” he said in a breakfast meeting with journalists.
Spanish law gives its courts jurisdiction beyond national borders in cases
of torture, war crimes and other heinous offenses, based on a doctrine known
as universal justice, but the government has made clear it wants to rein in
Last month, a group of human rights lawyers asked Judge Baltasar Garzon, famous
for indicting ex-Chilean ruler Augusto Pinochet in 1998, to consider filing
charges against the six Americans. Under Spanish law, the judge then asked prosecutors
for a recommendation on whether to open a full-blown probe.
National Court prosecutors have not formally announced their decision, but
Conde-Pumpido is the country’s top law-enforcement official and has the ultimate
say. While an investigative judge like Garzon is not bound by the prosecutors’
recommendation, it would be highly unusual for a case to proceed without their
A senior court official told The Associated Press that a formal announcement
would come Friday. He said prosecutors would stop short of an outright call
for dismissal of the case, but would raise a series of legal objections that
would make it impossible for it to proceed in its current form.
He spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to talk to
Coming less than three months after the Bush administration left office, the
case was the first of several international efforts to indict former administration
officials. Human rights groups have also tried to bring suit against Bush officials
in a German court.
In addition to Gonzales, the complaint named ex-Undersecretary of Defense Douglas
Feith; former Vice President Dick Cheney’s chief of staff, David Addington;
Justice Department officials John Yoo and Jay S. Bybee; and Pentagon lawyer
It alleged that the men — who have become known as “The Bush Six”
— cleared the path for torture by claiming in advice and legal opinions
that the president could ignore the Geneva Conventions, and by adopting an overly
narrow definition of which interrogation techniques constituted torture.
But Conde-Pumpido rejected that argument, saying the case had no merit because
the men did not themselves commit the alleged abuses.
“If one is dealing with a crime of mistreatment of prisoners of war, the
complaint should go against those who physically carried it out,” Conde-Pumpido
Gonzalo Boye, one of the human rights lawyers who brought the case in Spain,
said the decision by Conde-Pumpido was politically motivated and set a terrible
course for Spanish justice.
“The attorney general speaks of the court being turned into a plaything.
Well, I don’t think the attorney general’s office should be turned into a plaything
for politicians,” Boye told AP. “It is a terrible precedent if those
intellectually responsible for crimes can no longer be held accountable.”
The court official told AP that in addition to raising legal doubts, prosecutors
will say that Garzon should be replaced by another judge who is already investigating
whether secret CIA flights to or from Guantánamo entered Spanish airspace or
landed at Spanish airports.
Such a move would make it difficult for Garzon to try to keep the case alive
despite prosecutors’ objections, as he did in the Pinochet case.
Observers say the removal of Garzon would be another serious blow for the hopes
of human rights lawyers, who saw him as being sympathetic to their cause.
Most of the American officials named in the case have remained silent since
the allegations first surfaced in March. Feith, however, has called Spain’s
claim of jurisdiction “a national insult with harmful implications.”
Former President George W. Bush has steadfastly denied the U.S. tortured anyone.
The U.S. has acknowledged that Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the self-described plotter
of the Sept. 11 attacks, and a few other prisoners were waterboarded at secret
CIA prisons before being taken to Guantánamo. But the Bush administration insisted
that all interrogations were lawful.
Associated Press writer Jorge Sainz contributed to this report.