Top cybersecurity official quits, says NSA has too much power


by Rachel Oswald
March 10, 2009

Last week’s resignation of the top cybersecurity official for the Department of Homeland
Security has revealed a thorny bureaucratic rivalry between the National Security
Agency and the resigned official who accuses NSA of having too tight a hold
on cybersecurity.

After less than a year as director of the National Cyber Security Center, Rod
Beckstrom resigned on Friday, citing a lack of funding and efforts by the NSA
to dominate government cypersecurity. The Wall Street Journal has his
letter of resignation, which can be read here.

In the letter to DHS Secretary Janet Napolitano, Beckstrom charged that NSA
“effectively controls DHS cyber efforts” through employee detailees to NCSC
from NSA, technology insertions and the proposed move of the NCSC to NSA’s Fort
Meade facility.

“While acknowledging the critical importance of NSA to our intelligence efforts,
I believe this is a bad strategy on multiple grounds,” Beckstrom wrote. “The
intelligence culture is very different than a network operations or security

Beckstrom said as director he objected to the “subjugation” of NCSC under NSA
and had advocated for a “credible civilian government cybersecurity capability”
that cooperated with NSA but didn’t answer to it.

“This is a coordination body and it resides alongside or above the other centers,
but certainly not below them,” Beckstrom said of the NCSC in a Washington
interview after his resignation
. “In my view, it is very important
that there be independence for the [center], and that it be able to carry out
its role.”

In a
statement to Forbes
, DHS spokeswoman Amy Kudwa said the agency regrets
losing Beckstrom, but “has a strong relationship with the NSA and continues
to work in close collaboration with all of our federal partners on protecting
federal civilian networks. We look forward to our continued, positive working
relationship with all our partners on outreach to the private sector as we strive
to further secure our nation’s cyber networks.”

According to The Post’s Tuesday article, “Beckstrom said he decided to
leave roughly 10 days ago, after learning that orders were canceled for computers,
network equipment, furniture and office space in Arlington slated for his group.
While he officially reports to Department of Homeland Security Secretary Janet
Napolitano, Beckstrom said he has not yet had a meeting with her.”

The cypersecurity initiative to protect government networks was begun by the
Bush administration, reports
The Journal,
and the Obama administration is currently conducting
a 60-day review of that effort and its related policies. Recommendations on
the effort are expected next month.

Source URL:

Previous articleBush League Justice
Next articleGuant√°namo detainees say they planned September 11: report & excerpts

Since 2004, 911Truth.Org has educated the public about the suppressed realities of the September 11 attacks.

We worked with the 9/11 Families to pressure the Bush administration to convene an investigation into the deadliest attacks on US soil since Pearl Harbor. We attended many of the commission hearings and questioned commissioners and bird-dogged elected officials to get answers to the Unanswered Questions that remain so to this day.

We reported the contradictions, lies and omissions on the public record. 911Truth.Org staff have given hundreds of interviews on radio and mainstream network TV.

We cover a wide range of 9/11-related issues in publishing academic papers, original research, and opinion pieces.

We wish to thank our donors who have kept us on the web since 2004! We appreciate your continued support!

We continue to update the website to make the nearly 3000 articles easier to find, read and share. Thanks for visiting us!